HOBBIT WEEKLY · Original
Competitive Club Playing Time
For coachesCall the coach and ask directly how many minutes your son is likely to get and what he should improve.
My son plays U11 club soccer on a top 5 team in the state. There is a tournament coming up and the coach sends a message to the team saying he really wants to win and playing time is not guaranteed. He says to consider that before paying for the tournament and to call him if you have questions.
- Is this the right way for a coach to handle the situation? It seems like reaching out to the few people he already has in mind that will not play or play very little, and talking to them privately would be much better.
- At this age level is it the norm to completely bench players? These are kids that normally play about half the game, make solid contributions, and attend all games and practices. I'm not sure if this is just the reality of competitive sports at this age or if the guy is going a little overboard.
There are 4-5 subs on the team. What do you guys think?
Update - This is in Texas. The confidence of my kid getting crushed is a major concern. He feels like a normal part of the team until this happens, then he feels like he doesn't belong? I'm leaning towards just going and hoping to get at least a little playing time vs completely excluding ourselves from a major team event.
Top replies, most upvoted first
- (+26) Clubs do this all the time. I'm a fully even play-time coach. And I'll be the first to say, tournaments are rough. There are a lot of emotions on the line, especially if you win a couple games and have a shot at the championship. That said, I refuse to bench kids at the youth level. I coach because I enjoy developing kids, and crushing a kid by telling them they aren't good enough to play is the opposite of what I am in it for.
- (+25) This isn't about age level. This is about competitive level. I appreciate the coach's transparency. He's setting expectations before parents commit their time and money. I coach a U11 bronze team, and I wouldn't approach playing time this way, but you describe your team a top-five team in the state. Competitive level matters more than age here. If you're uncomfortable with playing time being determined by the desire to win, you should consider a less competitive team. You signed up for this.
- (+20) At that age, that feels a tad much - but, I think it’s healthy that he is communicating it? I guess? Bring it up in passing and see what the other parents are saying Edit: if this is a prestigious event, it’s way less weird
- (+11) He said to call him if you have questions. If you think your son is not one of their top players, I'd suggest calling him and asking him directly whether your son would see decent minutes during the tournament. Better yet, ask him where your son's areas of improvement are, and see if you can help your son work on them outside of team practice. As long as playtime is more equitable in league games, I don't see anything wrong with competing to win in a tournament. Winning sometimes matters and if there is a realistic chance the team can do well and place high in a tournament, the kids should be...
- (+8) This isn't normal for a lot of competitive teams, but this is what I'd call top team problems. The best teams in our area are far more likely to not give playing time to each player, since the reason they can recruit players is based on the performance of those top teams. I would say that if you are playing for one of the best clubs, and on their first team it's likely that your playing time is performance based.
- (+8) You want to tell everyone your kid is on a "Top 5" team in Texas but then complain about playing to win. Play at a lower level if that is a concern.
- (+7) What state? If one like CA with 1300+ teams at U11 there is an element of prestige that’s important with a top 5 team (the rankings really aren’t that arbitrary that far up). The club cares about reputations, recruiting into the pipeline, etc. If there are 6-8 flights of teams then there are plenty of options available for parents who demand equal playing time, etc. Sucks to be on the receiving end but I guess the upside is at least you know ahead of it.
- (+5) I guess think of the flip side-he makes everyone pay for the tournament and some kids barely play. Sounds like with 4-5 subs, everyone should play as opposed to being benched the whole game.
95 comments
Reprinted in full from the original. Copyright stays with the author and the original publisher.
Featured in Hobbit Weekly, Issue 6Coaching guide names touchline phrases to stop using
More in Coaching and communication
- The preseason talk in youth soccer: rules and standards from day oneAprende Entrenando · 16 Nov
- Group management in youth soccer: raising the demands without losing the locker room's trustAprende Entrenando · 12 Nov
- Youth Soccer Methodology: The 6 Principles for Building Successful AcademiesAprende Entrenando · 2 Nov
- What are the grassroots coaching fundamentals?England Football Learning · 30 Oct
