HOBBIT WEEKLY · Original
Effects of Combined Sprint and Plyometric Training vs Plyometric Training only on Physical Fitness and Sport-Specific Performance in Male Pubertal Soccer Players
For coachesIf you run a 30-minute block for your U14s, the sprint or change-of-direction rep came straight after the jumps, so the order is worth copying rather than splitting the two.
Abstract
Background. Sprint (ST) and plyometric training (PT) are well-established methods for improving physical fitness and sport-specific performance in youth athletes. However, the effects of their combination remain unclear.
Aim. This study investigated the effects of an 8-week combined ST and PT program (SPT), PT-only program, and active control (CG) on physical fitness and sport-specific performance in young male soccer players.
Methods. Forty-six pubertal Tier 2 training and performance caliber, male soccer players (13.9 to 14.2 years; maturity offset = 0.18 to 0.78 years from peak height velocity) participated in the study. Training was conducted twice weekly (2 × 30 min) over 8 weeks and was integrated into regular soccer sessions. The SPT program consisted of a progressive sequence of plyometric exercises (countermovement, line, drop jumps, and single-leg jumps/push-offs), immediately followed by a prescribed 10 to 15-m sprint or change-of-direction (CoD) task. The PT group performed the same plyometric exercises and exercise order without the subsequent sprint or CoD component. Training loads were monitored using the OMNI 0 to 10 RPE scale. The CG continued their regular soccer-specific training. Assessments included dynamic balance, muscle strength (reactive strength) and power (standing long jump, countermovement jump, five-jump test), speed (10-m and 30-m linear sprints), CoD speed with and without the ball, and sport-specific performance (throw-in and standing-kick tests).
Results. Significant group × time interactions were observed for most outcomes (p < 0.05), with partial eta-squared (ηp2) values ranging from 0.33 to 0.81. Significant interactions were found for dynamic balance (ηp2 = 0.66), reactive strength (ηp2 = 0.33), power (ηp2 = 0.65 to 0.81), 10-m sprint performance (ηp2 = 0.42), CoD speed (ηp2 = 0.44 to 0.45), and sport-specific performance (ηp2 = 0.73 to 0.78). Bonferroni-adjusted between-group comparisons indicated significant differences between SPT and PT for selected outcomes, including dynamic balance, power (five-jump and countermovement jump tests), speed (10-m sprint and 15-m CoD without the ball), and throw-in performance, whereas no significant SPT to PT differences were detected for the remaining outcomes. Significant pre to post-improvements were observed across the assessed outcomes in the SPT group, while PT also produced significant improvements in several measures and the CG showed limited or non-significant changes. Although both SPT and PT significantly improved 30-m sprint performance, the group × time interaction did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.060, ηp2 = 0.12).
Conclusions. An 8-week combined SPT intervention was associated with greater performance than PT alone for selected physical fitness and sport-specific outcomes, particularly dynamic balance, power and throw-in performance, in pubertal male Tier 2 soccer players. However, these benefits were outcome-specific and were not observed across all assessed measures.
Background
Soccer is a dynamic and physically demanding sport that requires players to perform a wide range of explosive actions throughout a match [1, 2]. These actions such as rapid accelerations and decelerations, changes of direction (CoD), powerful jumps, and maximal sprinting are fundamental to both offensive and defensive performance [3, 4]. Given the intermittent nature of match play and the frequent need for high-intensity efforts, optimizing key physical capacities in youth soccer players is essential for enhancing performance, supporting long-term talent development [5].
Youth athletes are particularly responsive to training stimuli due to ongoing physical maturation and neuromuscular performance, making targeted training interventions especially effective during this developmental stage [5]. Although regular soccer practice contributes to general fitness, it may be insufficient to elicit maximal improvements in neuromuscular qualities (e.g., sprint and CoD speed, jump height) required for elite-level soccer performance [6]. Consequently, structured supplementary training methods are commonly integrated into youth development programs to address specific performance-related attributes.
Among these methods, plyometric training (PT) characterized by exercises utilizing the stretch-shortening cycle (SSC) has consistently been shown to enhance muscular power, jump performance, acceleration, and CoD speed [5, 7, 8]. These adaptations are underpinned by improvements in muscle to tendon stiffness, neural activation, and rate of force development [9]. In addition, sprint training (ST) plays a crucial role in developing linear sprint and CoD speed, acceleration capacity, and repeated sprint ability, all of which are decisive determinants of soccer performance [2, 10]. A strong rationale, therefore, exists for combining these two modalities to provide complementary physiological and neuromuscular stimuli.
PT enhances the neuromuscular system’s ability to generate force rapidly [9], while ST reinforces sport-specific motor patterns during high-velocity running [11]. The combined approach of PT and ST (SPT) may elicit greater performance gains than either modality alone, potentially through mechanisms, such as post-activation performance enhancement (PAPE), whereby PT acutely enhances subsequent sprint performance [12 to 15]. Supporting this concept, Niering, Heckmann [16] demonstrated that a SPT program produced greater improvements in both linear sprint and CoD speed compared with ST alone in youth soccer players with Tier 2 training and performance caliber. Similarly, Aloui, Souhail [1] reported significant improvements in dynamic balance, following an 8-week SPT intervention in U-15 Tier 2 male soccer players. Collectively, these findings indicate that SPT effectively enhances reactive strength- and power-related performance in youth soccer players [1, 17, 18]. However, it remains unclear whether SPT provides superior benefits compared with PT alone, particularly across a broad range of physical and sport-specific outcomes, as most previous studies have compared combined sprint and plyometric training with control conditions rather than with PT-only interventions. Participants in the present study were at or near peak height velocity (circa-PHV), a developmental stage during which rapid growth and biological maturation can substantially influence training responsiveness, physical performance, and injury risk [19, 20]. Around PHV, rapid changes in body dimensions, neuromuscular coordination, and musculoskeletal structures may temporarily alter movement efficiency and increase susceptibility to growth-related and overuse injuries, particularly when training loads are excessive or poorly managed [21, 22]. Consequently, training during this period requires careful consideration of exercise selection, mechanical loading, progression, recovery, and individual maturation status [22]. There is extensive literature demonstrating the effectiveness of PT programs in youth without injuries [20, 23 to 27]. Importantly, this does not imply that ST or PT is inherently inappropriate during circa-PHV. Much rather, training loads should be appropriately managed and progressively adjusted according to the athlete's developmental status [22]. Sprint and power adaptations may also differ across pre-, circa-, and post-PHV athletes [28 to 30]. In particular, circa-PHV youth may demonstrate reduced responsiveness to ST despite greater absolute sprint performance, potentially reflecting transient coordination and movement-efficiency changes associated with rapid growth, sometimes described as “adolescent awkwardness” [30]. Therefore, examining the effects of SPT, specifically in circa-PHV players is warranted while considering both its potential performance benefits and the need for appropriate training-load management during this sensitive developmental stage [20, 22, 27].
Despite these challenges, combined SPT has the potential to improve measures of strength, power, linear sprint, and CoD speed, and sport-specific performance during circa-PHV. The high-velocity, reactive nature of both modalities also supports adaptation to maturational changes, facilitating performance gains despite temporary coordination constraints. Although some models propose sensitive periods for training, scientific evidence supports continuous development of strength, power, and speed across maturation stages [21, 30]. This study adds to limited evidence that SPT may outperform PT alone in circa-PHV youth, highlighting the importance of maturation-informed, individualized programming.
Therefore, the purpose of this study was to compare the effects of a SPT program with a PT-only and an active control group (CG) training program on dynamic balance (Y-balance test composite score: CS-YBT), reactive strength index (RSI) and power (standing long jump: SLJ, countermovement jump: CMJ, five-jump test: FJT, and absolute leg stiffness), linear sprint (10- and 30-m sprint) and CoD speed with (CoDB) and without (CoD) the ball, and sport-specific performance (throwing-in and standing kick) in Tier 2 male pubertal soccer players. Based on the existing literature [1, 16, 18], it was hypothesized that SPT would elicit greater improvements in physical fitness than PT alone and CG. It was further hypothesized that both training interventions would result in greater performance gains than an active control condition. Findings of this study may assist practitioners in making evidence-based decisions regarding the inclusion of SPT for optimizing physical fitness in youth soccer players.
Methods
Study Design
The present study employed a three-arm, parallel-group randomized controlled trial to investigate the effects of an 8-week PT program compared with PT and an active CG on physical fitness and sport-specific performance in male pubertal soccer players. The study was conducted in Manouba, Tunisia, during March and April, 2025. Participants were assessed before and after the intervention using a pre-test-to-post-test design. Training was performed twice weekly for approximately 30 min per session and integrated into the players’ regular soccer-training schedule.
The SPT group performed SPT exercises, in which each PT exercise was followed immediately by a short sprint or CoD effort. The PT group performed the corresponding PT exercises without the subsequent sprint or CoD component, whereas the CG continued its regular soccer-specific training without an additional structured plyometric or sprint intervention. The training programs were progressively prescribed over the 8-week intervention, with exercise volume and loading monitored according to the pre-defined training schedule (Table 3). Training exposure was, therefore, documented for each condition rather than assumed to be fully equivalent across groups.
The primary outcomes comprised physical fitness and sport-specific performance measures, including dynamic balance, RSI, CMJ, SLJ, FJT, leg stiffness, 10- and 30-m sprint performance, CoD performance with and without the ball, throwing-in distance, and standing-kick performance. Group differences in changes from pre- to post-intervention were examined using group × time analyses. This design allowed assessment of whether the addition of sprint training to PT training resulted in greater changes in physical fitness and sport-specific performance than PT alone or regular soccer training.
Participants
The sample size estimation was computed using G*Power software (version 3.1.6). Based on findings from a related study [1] examining the effects of SPT on 5-m linear sprint speed (Cohen’s f = 0.255) in Tier 2 U-17 male soccer players, an a priori power analysis with a type I error of 0.05% and 80% statistical power was computed. The analysis indicated that 42 participants would represent a sufficient sample. Accordingly, a total of 46 trained male pubertal soccer players from the same soccer team were recruited to participate in this study. According to the classification proposed by McKay, Stellingwerff [28], the participants were classified as Tier 2 (trained/developmental) soccer players. Players were randomly assigned to the SPT (n = 16), PT (n = 15), or CG (n = 15) (Table 1). All participants practiced systematic soccer training for at least 3 to 4 years prior to study participation. Sport-specific training mainly focused on enhancing soccer specific technical skills. Of note, all groups followed the same soccer-training program under the supervision of the same coaches. The SPT and the PT groups conducted two weekly training sessions implemented following the warm-up of regular soccer-training sessions (Table 2). Participants’ biological maturity status was estimated based on the maturity-offset method using the prediction equation of Mckay et al. [28]. Participants were eligible if they were male youth soccer players within the targeted pubertal stage, regularly participated in organized football/soccer training and competition, and met the pre-defined maturity and training-level criteria of the study. Players were excluded if they had a current musculoskeletal injury or medical condition preventing full participation in training or testing, had undergone surgery or sustained a major injury during the preceding period, or were unable to complete the study protocol. Participants were also excluded from the final analysis if they failed to attend the required training sessions or post-intervention assessments according to the pre-defined adherence criteria.
Attendance and adherence were monitored throughout the intervention. Participants who withdrew voluntarily, sustained an injury or illness that prevented completion of the intervention, or failed to meet the pre-defined attendance requirements were considered dropouts. The number and reasons for participant withdrawal were recorded and reported in the study flow diagram. The final analysis included only participants who completed the required assessments and intervention protocol.
Before participation in this study, the subjects were given a letter that included written information about the study and a request for consent from the parents to allow their children to participate in the study. Legal representatives and subjects provided informed consent after thorough explanation of the objectives and scope of this project, the procedures, risks, and benefits of the study. This study was conducted following the latest version of the Declaration of Helsinki and the protocol was approved by the Local Ethics Committee of the National Center of Medicine and Science of Sports of Tunis (CNMSS-LR09SEP01) before the commencement of the study. None of the participating players had a history of psychological and musculoskeletal, neurological, or orthopedic disorders 6 months prior to the start of the study.
Procedure
One week prior to the start of the study, a familiarization session was scheduled to allow players to become acquainted with the tests and SPT and PT exercises. Participants of the SPT and PT groups received instructions on the proper exercise techniques. The same test sequence was applied during pre- and post-tests. More specifically, athletes performed the Y-balance, RSI, power (SLJ, CMJ and submaximal hopping), followed by the 10-, 20- and 30-m linear sprint and CoDB and CoD, and sport-specific performance (throwing and standing kicking) tests. Before testing, all participants conducted a standardized 10-min warm-up which consisted of submaximal running (e.g., running, skipping), balance exercises (e.g., forward or backward beam walking, single-leg stance on unstable devices) and landing drills (e.g., snap downs, 1-leg drop squat). All tests were separated by a 5 to 10-min rest period. The rest between test trials was 3 min. The best of two trials was used for further statistical analyses.
Anthropometrics
Standing height and body mass were measured using a wall-mounted stadiometer (Florham Park, NJ, USA) and an electronic scale (Baty International, West Sussex, UK), respectively. Subcutaneous adiposity was estimated from the sum of skinfold measurements obtained with Harpenden calipers. All anthropometric assessments were performed using standardized procedures. Biological maturation was estimated non-invasively using the Moore et al. [29] approach, which combines chronological age and standing height to estimate maturity offset relative to peak height velocity (PHV). The maturity-offset equation applied to the male participants was: maturity offset = − 7.999994 + (0.0036124 × age × height). The resulting value represents the estimated number of years before or after PHV.
Physical Fitness Tests
Dynamic Balance
Dynamic postural control was evaluated using the YBT following a standardized procedure adapted from previously published protocols [31, 32]. All assessments were performed barefoot. Participants maintained a single-leg stance on the dominant limb, positioning the most distal aspect of the great toe at the designated central point of the YBT platform. While maintaining this position, they reached as far as possible with the non-stance limb in the anterior, posteromedial, and posterolateral directions. The heel of the supporting limb had to remain in contact with the platform throughout each trial. Reach distances were recorded to the nearest 0.5 cm using the YBT measurement system. A trial was repeated if the participant lost balance, displaced the stance foot, lifted the heel, or failed to return the reaching limb to the starting position in a controlled manner. For each direction, the best successful reach distance was retained. The composite YBT score (CS-YBT) was calculated as
Data from our own laboratory indicated a good test to retest reliability of the CS-YBT (ICC = 0.85; SEM = 6.56%).
Reactive Strength Index
RSI was predicted from the maximal hopping protocols and was performed in the same manner as previously described [33]. The maximal hopping protocol involved participants performing five repeated bilateral maximal vertical hops in place (stationary) on the contact mat. Participants were instructed to maximize jump height and minimize ground-contact time [34]. The first jump in each trial was not included in the analysis. Jump height and ground-contact time were averaged across the four remaining hops and used to calculate the RSI as follows:
Our data indicated good test to retest reliability with ICC = 0.81 and SEM = 5.48%.
Proxies of Power
Horizontal Jumps
For the SLJ test, participants stood stationary with the toes aligned level with the start line and were instructed to push-off vigorously and jump forward as far as possible. Participants were allowed the use of a countermovement with arms and body swing. The distance jumped from the start line at takeoff to the position of the heel upon landing was measured in centimeters using a metal tape measure. Data from our own laboratory indicated an excellent, test to retest reliability with ICC = 0.95 and SEM = 3.27%.
The FJT was applied in accordance with recommendations provided by Sabato, Walch [35]. From an upright standing position, with both feet flat on the ground, players tried to cover as much horizontal distance as possible with five forward bouncing strides by alternating left-leg and right-leg ground contacts. The covered distance was measured to the nearest 1 cm using a tape measure. Data from our own laboratory indicated an excellent, test to retest reliability with an ICC = 0.96 and SEM = 0.21% for youth soccer players.
Vertical Jump and Hopping Assessments
Two vertical performance tasks were administered, the CMJ and a submaximal bilateral hopping test. During both tests, participants kept their hands on their hips to restrict the contribution of the upper limbs and reduce lateral or horizontal movement. They were instructed to take off and land with the knees and ankles extended and to maintain a consistent landing position. Jump and hopping characteristics were measured with an Ergojump system (ErgojumpP; Globus Italia, Codognè, Italy), which automatically recorded flight and ground-contact times. At least 5 min of passive recovery was provided between the different tests.
For the CMJ, participants started from an upright standing position, performed a rapid downward countermovement to a self-selected depth, and immediately jumped vertically as high as possible. Three attempts were completed, with approximately 2 min of recovery between trials, and the highest jump was retained for analysis. Data from our own laboratory indicated a good test to retest reliability (ICC = 0.87; SEM = 0.80%).
Absolute leg stiffness was estimated from bilateral submaximal hopping using the relationship between flight and ground-contact times [34, 35]. Participants completed 20 consecutive hops at a target frequency of 2.0 Hz, maintained using an electronic metronome. To minimize the influence of acceleration and fatigue, the first five and final five hops were excluded. The middle 10 hops were averaged for the analysis. Leg stiffness (kN · m⁻1) was subsequently calculated from mean contact and flight times and participant body mass [34]. The test demonstrated good test to retest reliability (ICC = 0.87; SEM = 2.80%) in our laboratory.
Linear Sprint Performance
Sprint performance was assessed over 10 and 30 m to characterize short-distance acceleration and longer-distance sprinting capacity. For the 10-m test, participants began from a stationary standing position immediately behind the first timing gate and sprinted maximally through the 10-m distance. For the 30-m assessment, participants adopted a standing position 30 cm behind the starting line and were instructed to accelerate and run maximally over 30 m. Timing was recorded automatically using photocell gates (Brower Timing Systems, Salt Lake City, UT, USA), positioned approximately 0.4 m above the ground and accurate to 0.01 s. Two attempts were completed for each distance, with a minimum of 2 min recovery between trials. The fastest time recorded for each distance was used for statistical analysis. Laboratory reliability testing demonstrated excellent reliability for both sprint distances (ICC = 0.93 to 0.94; SEM = 1.17 to 1.19%).
Change-of-Direction Performance
CoD speed was evaluated using 15-m tests performed with (15-m CoDB) and without the ball (15-m CoD) [36]. Participants began 3 m before the first timing gate, completed an initial 3-m straight section, and then negotiated a 3-m slalom formed by three 1.6-m high markers positioned 1.5-m apart. After the slalom, participants cleared a 0.5-m hurdle located 2 m beyond the final marker and completed a final 7-m straight sprint before crossing the second timing gate.
The ball-based version followed the same course but required participants to maintain ball control throughout the task. During the hurdle section, the ball was passed underneath the hurdle, while the participant jumped over it. The ball was then directed toward one of two small targets positioned diagonally to either side of the hurdle before the participant completed the final 7-m sprint [33].
Two trials were performed for each condition, separated by approximately 3 min of recovery. The fastest trial was retained for analysis. Test to retest reliability in our laboratory was excellent (ICC = 0.90 to 0.93; SEM = 0.57 to 0.68%).
Soccer-Specific Performance
Throw-In
A proxy of upper-body power was assessed using a standardized maximal-distance throw-in test [34]. From a standing position, participants used both hands to perform a regulation-style soccer throw-in and were instructed to achieve maximal distance. The landing distance of the ball was measured to the nearest 0.2 m. The test demonstrated good test to retest reliability (ICC = 0.88; SEM = 2.47%).
Standing Kick
Standing-kick performance was assessed as a measure combining lower-limb muscle power and soccer kicking performance [9, 35]. Participants kicked a stationary ball maximally without a preceding run-up. The non-kicking foot was positioned beside the ball, while the kicking leg was moved backward before a maximal forward kicking action. The distance from the initial ball position to the first point of ground contact was measured to the nearest 0.2 m using a 50-m measuring tape. Participants received the same instruction for each attempt: to kick the ball as far as possible. Test to retest reliability was excellent (ICC = 0.90; SEM = 3.19%).
Training Programs
During the 2025 in-season period (February to March), participants completed an 8-week intervention consisting of two supervised sessions per week. The SPT and PT programs were integrated into the regular soccer sessions and replaced the general conditioning component, while the CG continued its usual soccer-specific training. Each session lasted approximately 90 min and comprised a standardized 15-min warm-up, a 30-min experimental training block, approximately 40 min of soccer-specific training, and a 5-min cool-down. The warm-up included submaximal running (forward, backward, and lateral), dynamic stretching, accelerations, and jumping activities (approximately 10 min), followed by 5 min of passing exercises. The cool-down consisted of jogging and dynamic stretching. No additional conditioning activities were performed on these days.
The SPT program combined plyometric exercises with immediately subsequent sprint or CoD efforts. The exercise sequence was standardized across sessions and consisted of: (1) CMJ followed by a 10-m sprint; (2) line jumps followed by a 4 × 5-m CoD drill; (3) drop jump + one-step followed by a 15-m CoD sprint; (4) single-leg cone jumps in the front-to-back direction followed by a 10-m sprint; (5) single-leg cone jumps in the side-to-side direction followed by a 10-m CoD effort; and (6) single-leg box push-offs. The sprint or CoD effort was performed immediately after the corresponding PT exercise. The weekly progression of sets and repetitions is presented in Table 3.
The PT-only program used the same plyometric exercises and exercise order as the SPT group but without the subsequent sprint or CoD component. The weekly progression in sets and repetitions is presented in Table 3. Importantly, according to the actual training schedule shown in Table 3, the SPT and PT conditions did not involve identical numbers of plyometric repetitions. The distinction between the two conditions was based on the addition of sprint/CoD efforts to the plyometric exercises in SPT, together with the prescribed progression in plyometric volume.
For both intervention groups, training load was progressively increased across the 8-week period. The prescribed progression is detailed in Table 3, with the number of sets and repetitions increasing during weeks 1 to 4 and then being adjusted during weeks 5 to 8. Exercise intensity and technical quality were monitored throughout each session. Perceived exertion was progressively increased across the intervention, from approximately 3 to 9 on the 0 to 10 OMNI scale, according to the planned progression and participant tolerance.
The CG continued its regular soccer-specific training without the additional SPT or PT intervention. The soccer component consisted of technical and tactical exercises and small-sided games and was delivered for approximately 40 min within the same overall session structure.
All intervention sessions were supervised by qualified coaches and sport scientists to ensure standardized exercise execution, appropriate progression, and adherence to the prescribed program. Participants were instructed to prioritize movement quality and technical execution, and training was modified when necessary according to individual tolerance and maturation-related considerations. A detailed description of the weekly progression for both intervention conditions is provided in Table 3.
Statistical Analyses
Data are presented as group means and standard deviations (SD). After confirming data normality using the Shapiro to Wilk test, a MANOVA was performed to examine baseline between-group differences. A 3 × 2 mixed ANOVA was then conducted with group (SPT, PT, and CG) as the between-subject factor and time (pre-test and post-test) as the within-subject factor to determine training effects. For each outcome, the main effect of time and the group × time interaction were examined. When a significant group × time interaction was detected, Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise between-group comparisons (SPT vs PT, SPT vs CG, and PT vs CG) were performed, and mean differences with their corresponding 95% confidence intervals (CIs) and adjusted p values were reported. Effect sizes for the main effects and group × time interactions were reported as partial eta-squared (ηp2) directly from the mixed ANOVA, without conversion to Cohen’s d. Within-group pre to post-Cohen’s d values were additionally calculated as the mean change divided by the pooled SD of the pre- and post-test scores: d = (Mpost − Mpre)/SDpooled. Cohen’s d values were interpreted as small (0.20 to 0.49), moderate (0.50 to 0.79), and large (≥ 0.80) [37]. Intra-session reliability was assessed during a single test session by comparing repeated measurements obtained under the same conditions. Participants completed a familiarization session before testing to ensure that they understood and could correctly perform each test. The reliability results, therefore, reflect the consistency of repeated measurements within the same session. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. All pairwise comparisons were adjusted for multiple comparisons using the Bonferroni procedure. All analyses were performed using SPSS version 20.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
Results
All participants received the treatments as allocated. The overall rate of compliance to training interventions was 95%. No significant between-group baseline differences were observed for any descriptive variable or physical fitness measure. The main effects of time, and group-by-time interactions are displayed in Table 4. Where appropriate, Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons were used to further examine between-group differences.
Dynamic Balance
Findings indicated a significant group × time interaction for the CS-YBT (ηp2 = 0.66; p < 0.001) (Table 4). Bonferroni-adjusted between-group comparisons indicated higher performance in SPT than PT (MD = 9.697, 95% CI [3.985, 15.410], p < 0.001) and CG (MD = 6.015, 95% CI [0.303, 11.728], p = 0.036), whereas PT and CG did not differ significantly (p = 0.364). Within groups, SPT showed a large pre-to-post-improvement (Δ = 18.03%; p < 0.001; d = 2.70), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 7.54%; p < 0.001; d = 1.05). In contrast, no significant improvement was observed in CG (Δ = 0.58%; d = 0.07; p > 0.05).
Reactive Strength Index
Training resulted in a significant group × time interaction for RSI (ηp2 = 0.33; p < 0.001). However, the pairwise between-group comparisons were not statistically significant (SPT vs PT: p = 1.000; SPT vs CG: p = 0.163; PT vs CG: p = 0.132). Within groups, a large pre-to-post-improvement was observed in SPT (Δ = 43.92%; p < 0.001; d = 1.41), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 18.14%; p < 0.001; d = 0.41). According to the pre-defined thresholds, the magnitude of the latter effect was small rather than moderate. No significant change was found in CG (Δ = 1.41%; d = 0.05; p > 0.05).
Proxies of Power
The Standing Long Jump Test
A significant group × time interaction was observed for the SLJ (ηp2 = 0.81; p < 0.001) (Table 4). Nevertheless, Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons did not identify statistically significant differences between SPT and PT (p = 0.066), SPT and CG (p = 0.354), or PT and CG (p = 1.000). Within groups, SPT showed a large pre-to-post-improvement (Δ = 12.22%; p < 0.001; d = 1.47), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 5.49%; p < 0.001; d = 0.61). No significant change was observed in CG (Δ = 0.27%; d = 0.03; p > 0.05).
The Five Jump Test
A significant group × time interaction was identified for the FJT (ηp2 = 0.81; p < 0.001) (Table 4). Bonferroni-adjusted comparisons indicated a significant difference between SPT and PT (MD = 1.055 m, 95% CI [0.206, 1.904], p = 0.010), whereas SPT vs CG (p = 0.128) and PT vs CG (p = 0.983) were not statistically significant. Within groups, SPT showed a large improvement (Δ = 22.46%; p < 0.001; d = 2.70), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 7.89%; p < 0.001; d = 0.66). No significant improvement was observed in CG (Δ = 0.53%; d = 0.05; p > 0.05).
The Countermovement Jump
A significant group × time interaction was identified for the CMJ (ηp2 = 0.65; p < 0.001). Pairwise comparisons indicated a significant difference between SPT and PT (MD = 4.833 cm, 95% CI [0.931, 8.735], p = 0.011), whereas SPT vs CG (p = 0.200) and PT vs CG (p = 0.727) were not significant. SPT showed a large within-group improvement (Δ = 17.32%; p < 0.001; d = 1.31), while PT showed a moderate improvement (Δ = 10.01%; p < 0.001; d = 0.57). No significant improvement was detected in CG (Δ = 0.44%; d = 0.03; p > 0.05).
Absolute Leg Stiffness
Findings showed a significant group × time interaction for leg stiffness (ηp2 = 0.36; p < 0.001). However, none of the Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons was statistically significant (SPT vs PT: MD = 16.452 N/kg, 95% CI [− 9.162, 42.066], p = 0.351; SPT vs CG: MD = − 0.705 N/kg, 95% CI [− 26.319, 24.908], p = 1.000; PT vs CG: MD = − 17.157 N/kg, 95% CI [− 43.181, 8.866], p = 0.323). SPT showed a pre-to-post-improvement (Δ = 55.80%; d = 0.50), whereas PT (Δ = 0.21%; d = 0.00) and CG (Δ = 0.26%; d = 0.00) showed negligible changes.
Linear Sprint Speed
A significant group × time interaction was found for the 10-m sprint (ηp2 = 0.42; p < 0.001), whereas the group × time interaction for the 30-m sprint was not statistically significant (ηp2 = 0.12; p = 0.060) (Table 4). For the 10-m sprint, Bonferroni-adjusted comparisons indicated significant differences between SPT And PT (MD = − 0.122 s, 95% CI [− 0.238, − 0.005], p = 0.039) and SPT and CG (MD = − 0.183 s, 95% CI [− 0.300, − 0.066], p = 0.001), whereas PT and CG did not differ significantly (MD = − 0.062 s, 95% CI [− 0.180, 0.057], p = 0.607). Within groups, SPT significantly improved both 10-m (Δ = 13.53%; p < 0.001; d = 1.97) and 30-m sprint performance (Δ = 4.35%; p < 0.001; d = 0.76). PT also showed significant improvements in the 10-m (Δ = 5.09%; p < 0.001; d = 0.71) and 30-m (Δ = 2.94%; p < 0.001; d = 0.47) sprints. No significant pre-to-post-changes were observed in CG for either sprint outcome (both p > 0.05). Despite the significant pairwise differences in marginal means reported for the 30-m sprint, the group × time interaction was not statistically significant (p = 0.060); therefore, no differential training effect or superiority of SPT is inferred for this outcome.
Change-of-Direction Speed
The 15-m Change-of-Direction Speed Test Without the Ball
A significant group × time interaction was observed for the 15-m CoD test (ηp2 = 0.45; p < 0.001) (Table 4). Bonferroni-adjusted comparisons indicated a significant difference between SPT and PT (MD = − 0.266 s, 95% CI [− 0.436, − 0.097], p = 0.001). In contrast, SPT vs CG (MD = − 0.099 s, 95% CI [− 0.269, 0.070], p = 0.454) and PT vs CG (MD = 0.167 s, 95% CI [− 0.005, 0.339], p = 0.060) were not statistically significant. Within groups, SPT showed a large improvement (Δ = 9.21%; p < 0.001; d = 1.43), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 2.83%; p < 0.001; d = 0.52). CG showed no significant improvement (Δ = 0.61%; d = 0.07; p > 0.05).
The 15-m Change-of-Direction Speed Test with the Ball
A significant group × time interaction was observed for the 15-m CoD with ball test (ηp2 = 0.44; p < 0.001). None of the Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons was statistically significant (SPT vs PT: MD = − 0.210 s, 95% CI [− 0.472, 0.053], p = 0.160; SPT vs CG: MD = − 0.205 s, 95% CI [− 0.468, 0.058], p = 0.175; PT vs CG: MD = 0.004 s, 95% CI [− 0.263, 0.271], p = 1.000). Within groups, SPT showed a large improvement (Δ = 8.71%; p < 0.01; d = 1.79), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 4.93%; p < 0.001; d = 0.68). No significant change was observed in CG (Δ = 0.36%; d = 0.06; p > 0.05).
Sport-Specific Performance
The Throwing-in Test
A significant group × time interaction was found for the throw-in test (ηp2 = 0.73; p < 0.001). Bonferroni-adjusted comparisons indicated significant differences between SPT and PT (MD = 1.762 m, 95% CI [0.223, 3.301], p = 0.020) and SPT and CG (MD = 1.781 m, 95% CI [0.242, 3.321], p = 0.018), whereas PT and CG did not differ significantly (MD = 0.019 m, 95% CI [− 1.545, 1.583], p = 1.000). Within groups, SPT showed a large improvement (Δ = 31.86%; p < 0.001; d = 2.01), while PT also improved significantly (Δ = 11.63%; p < 0.001; d = 0.68). CG showed no significant change (Δ = 0.11%; d = 0.01; p > 0.05).
The Standing Kick
A significant group × time interaction was found for the standing-kick test (ηp2 = 0.78; p < 0.001). However, none of the Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons reached statistical significance (SPT vs PT: MD = 4.642 m, 95% CI [− 0.095, 9.380], p = 0.056; SPT vs CG: MD = 3.285 m, 95% CI [− 1.452, 8.023], p = 0.274; PT vs CG: MD = − 1.357 m, 95% CI [− 6.170, 3.456], p = 1.000). Within groups, SPT showed a large improvement (Δ = 31.17%; p < 0.001; d = 2.01), while PT showed a moderate improvement (Δ = 15.50%; p < 0.001; d = 0.72). No significant improvement was observed in CG (Δ = 0.03%; d = 0.01; p > 0.05).
Discussion
In this study, we examined the effects of an 8-week SPT program compared with PT alone and a CG, integrated into soccer-specific training sessions, on physical fitness and sport-specific performance in male pubertal and trained (Tier 2 training and performance caliber) soccer players. Overall, twice-weekly SPT produced significant improvements across a broad range of physical fitness and sport-specific outcomes, with generally larger effects than those observed following PT or soccer-specific training alone. The clearest between-group advantages were observed for dynamic balance, reactive strength, power, short-distance sprinting, CoD, and sport-specific performance. These findings are broadly consistent with previous research reporting beneficial effects of combined sprint and PT in youth soccer players [1, 12]. However, the magnitude and statistical significance of the training effects varied across outcomes, and the 30-m sprint interaction did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.06). Therefore, the findings should be interpreted as evidence of broader performance benefits of SPT rather than uniformly superior effects across sprint measure.
SPT was associated with significant improvements in dynamic balance, and the PT group also demonstrated significant and large within-group improvements. Therefore, the present findings do not indicate that improvements in dynamic balance were exclusive to SPT. Rather, the observed group × time effect suggests that the magnitude of change differed among the training conditions. Dynamic balance is relevant to soccer, because it contributes to postural control during acceleration, deceleration, and directional changes [38]. The present findings are broadly consistent with Aloui et al. [1], who reported improvements in Y-balance performance following SPT training in U-19 male soccer players. However, differences in training protocols and participant characteristics should be considered when comparing these findings.
Significant improvements were also observed in RSI and several measures of lower-limb power performance, including SLJ, FJT, CMJ, and absolute leg stiffness, particularly following SPT. PT also produced significant improvements in several of these outcomes. Thus, the findings support the effectiveness of both training approaches for developing reactive and power performance, while the significant group × time effects observed for some variables suggest potentially greater improvements following SPT. These findings are consistent with previous studies reporting beneficial effects of PT and SPT on power performance in youth soccer players [1, 12]. Because physiological and neuromuscular mechanisms were not directly assessed, the present results cannot determine the specific mechanisms responsible for these adaptations.
Leg stiffness also improved following the training interventions, with greater changes observed following SPT. Leg stiffness is relevant to efficient force production during high-velocity movements [16], and previous research has reported improvements in stiffness-related characteristics following PT [39]. However, the present study did not include direct biomechanical or neuromuscular assessments; therefore, explanations concerning changes in force transmission, muscle activation, or stretch-reflex function remain speculative.
For sprint performance, both SPT and PT produced significant within-group improvements in the 10- and 20-m sprint tests, whereas the group × time interaction for the 30-m sprint did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.06). Accordingly, the findings indicate that both training approaches may improve short-distance sprint performance, while evidence for a differential advantage of SPT is stronger for some sprint outcomes than for the 30-m distance. This is relevant to soccer, because many sprint actions occur over relatively short distances [40]. Previous research has also reported improvements in sprint performance following both PT and SPT [15, 41]. Differences in participant maturation, training status, sprint distance, and intervention design should nevertheless be considered when comparing results across studies.
SPT also resulted in significant improvements in CoD performance with and without the ball, with the magnitude of change generally exceeding that observed in the other groups. CoD performance requires effective braking, force production, and re-acceleration [42]. The present findings suggest that incorporating sprint and CoD efforts alongside plyometric exercises may be beneficial for developing this performance quality. Similar improvements following combined training have been reported in youth soccer players [1, 15]. Nevertheless, the present study cannot determine whether these effects resulted from greater movement specificity, differences in mechanical loading, or other training-related factors.
Finally, SPT improved throwing-in distance and standing-kick performance, indicating improvements in these selected soccer-specific performance measures. Similar improvements in sport-specific performance following combined training have been reported previously [1, 12]. However, because the present study did not directly assess technical execution, movement strategy, or underlying physiological mechanisms, the observed improvements should be interpreted strictly as changes in measured performance outcomes. In particular, the present data do not allow definitive conclusions regarding training transfer or the mechanisms responsible for these changes.
An important consideration when interpreting these findings is the maturational status of the participants. The circa-PHV period is characterized by rapid changes in body dimensions, neuromuscular coordination, and musculoskeletal structures, which may influence training responsiveness and increase susceptibility to growth-related and overuse injuries when training loads are excessive or poorly managed [20, 22, 27]. This consideration is particularly relevant when prescribing PT because of its repeated mechanical impact. However, PT should not be considered inherently unsafe during puberty. Rather, the potential risk is likely to depend on the magnitude and management of the training stimulus, including exercise selection, volume, intensity, progression, recovery, previous training exposure, and individual maturation status [20, 22, 27]. Recent evidence also indicates that appropriately prescribed PT can improve power performance in adolescent soccer players, while adaptations may differ according to maturation status [43]. Accordingly, SPT around PHV should be progressively implemented and individualized, with practitioners monitoring overall training load and potential musculoskeletal symptoms.
Future research should investigate the dose to response relationship between sprint and plyometric loading and performance across different maturational stages. Longitudinal studies incorporating systematic injury surveillance are also warranted to determine whether different plyometric doses can optimize performance while minimizing growth-related injury risk in circa-PHV soccer players. Further biomechanical and physiological investigations may help clarify the mechanisms underlying the observed adaptations.
This study is not without limitations. First, the sample consisted exclusively of male pubertal Tier 2 soccer players; therefore, the findings cannot be generalized to female players, athletes of different maturation status, or players from other competitive levels. Second, although SPT was compared with PT and a CG, it was not contrasted with other relevant training modalities, such as isolated strength training or sprint-only programs. As a result, it cannot be determined whether the observed benefits were specific to the combined nature of SPT or would also occur following other single-mode interventions. In addition, the study focused on performance-based outcomes and did not directly assess physiological or neuromuscular mechanisms underpinning the observed improvements. Consequently, mechanistic interpretations remain speculative. Future research should compare SPT with other commonly implemented training approaches (e.g., resistance training or sprint-only training) and, where possible, include complementary assessments that help clarify the mechanisms underlying performance adaptations. Finally, the study included only male pubertal soccer players, which limits the generalizability of the findings to female youth soccer players or adults. Although the sample was appropriate for the study population and research objectives, future studies should replicate the intervention in female players to determine whether similar responses are observed across sexes.
Conclusions
Both SPT and PT were associated with improvements in several physical fitness and sport-specific performance outcomes in pubertal, trained (Tier 2) soccer players. However, the benefits of SPT over PT were outcome-specific, with significant between-group differences favoring SPT for dynamic balance, five-jump test performance, 10-m sprint, 15-m CoD performance without the ball, countermovement jump, and throw-in performance. No significant between-group differences were observed for the SLJ, RSI, leg stiffness, 15-m CoD performance with the ball, or standing kick. Although both groups improved 30-m sprint performance, the group × time interaction was not significant. These findings suggest that combining sprint and plyometric training may offer additional benefits over PT alone for selected physical fitness and sport-specific performance outcomes in pubertal Tier 2 soccer players, rather than providing a consistent advantage across all measures. Coaches may, therefore, consider incorporating appropriately designed sprint and plyometric exercises into youth soccer training when targeting specific performance qualities.
Chaouachi et al., Sports Medicine - Open, 2026, doi:10.1186/s40798-026-01155-1. Published under CC BY 4.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Reprinted in full from the original. Copyright stays with the author and the original publisher.
More in Body and injuries
- Comparative Effects of Different Neuromuscular Training Modalities and Doses on Lower-Limb Injury Prevention in Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysisSports Medicine - Open · 18 Nov
- ParticipACTION’s Early Years Report Card: Are Young Kids Developing Physical Literacy?Sport for Life · 12 Nov
- A Parent’s Guide to Strength and ConditioningWorking with Parents in Sport · 11 Nov
- Heading in youth soccer: The scientific and practical guide for coachesAprende Entrenando · 5 Nov
