HOBBIT WEEKLY · Full translation
Is 8-a-side soccer unique to Japan? Tell me whether we should have players train with odd numbers of players, like they do abroad, so the move to 11-a-side is easier
サカイク ↗Translated from Japanese
For coachesWhen you set up a small-sided game, count the triangles your shape creates rather than the number of players, and let the formation shift when the head count changes.
I agree with Japan's development guidelines that let everyone touch the ball in small-sided games, but 8-a-side is unique to Japan, isn't it? We received a consultation from a dad coach wondering: wouldn't having kids play 7-a-side or 9-a-side, odd numbers like overseas, make the transition to 11-a-side easier?
Tadashi Ikegami, who has served as a development coach at JEF United Ichihara Chiba and as Home Town Academy Director at Kyoto Sanga F.C., and who has coached more than 600,000 children in total, shares the key points of 8-a-side and odd-number practice and what matters in the U-10 age group. (Writing and composition: Yuko Shimazawa)
<Question from a dad coach>
Hello, nice to meet you.
I am involved with a local club as a parent and coach. (Coaching age group: U-10)
What I would like to ask about, rather than consult on, is "8-a-side" in the elementary school age group.
In Japan's development age groups, I think there are good aspects to guidelines aimed at small-sided games where everyone can be involved with the ball, but the number of players per age group differs from overseas, right? Isn't 8-a-side unique to Japan?
I hear overseas uses odd numbers, and it's said that makes the transition to 11-a-side easier, but is that true? If so, should we have them play 7-a-side or 9-a-side from around the upper grades?
If we use odd numbers, what would be the key points, for example? (Positioning, distance from the opponent, differences from 8-a-side)
It's not every year, but our team sometimes goes overseas and plays against local teams, so I wondered whether they might be confused once they get there, which is why I'm asking. (Though confusion and things not going well are also experiences, so that's fine.)
Thank you in advance.
<Advice from Ikegami>
Thank you for your consultation.
8-a-side in the development age groups is not unique to Japan; it is also used in other countries.
In Germany and elsewhere, the upper grades generally use 9-a-side, but it is very flexible there. Depending on the opponent that day, the team, or what they want to try, they change it, like "let's do 9 today" or "7."
Specifically, to go from 11 to, say, 9, you change a two-top to a one-top, pull out one defender and make it a three-back, or something like that. When reducing the number of players, they think about how the soccer system connects smoothly. As the age group goes down, it changes to 7-, 5-, and 3-a-side futsal-style games.
■ Even if the number of players changes, the basic idea, the formation of triangles, does not change
That said, even with 8-a-side, the basic idea does not change. In soccer, it is good if triangles are formed in various places.
If so, excluding the goalkeeper, you place three in defense, one midfield player in the middle, and two players spread wide slightly ahead. If there is a top there, it becomes 3-1-2-1 with seven field players, making it 8-a-side.
I would be happy if you could picture this in your head: there is one player in the center of defense, and if you connect the slightly advanced fullbacks on both sides and the center of midfield with lines, it forms a diamond. Next, if you connect the one central midfielder, the wide attackers on both sides, and the forward at the top, that also forms a diamond.
When you look at it, the left and right sides always form triangles. Connecting the left fullback, the left wide player, and the midfielder also makes a triangle. The right side is the same. In this way, the basic soccer idea of triangles can be learned in 8-a-side. I tell coaches who teach 8-a-side to have the players think that way.
In contrast, not a few coaches see it as 3-3-1. This is often seen even in J-League youth academies. When seen that way, triangles become harder to imagine.
■ Key points for using odd numbers
Next, let's talk about what the key points are for using odd numbers. With odd numbers, the field players become even, but if you play soccer while being conscious of the various triangles described above, the basics are the same.
In Japan too, since about 15 years ago, elementary school age groups have started building up from the goalkeeper. This is because around the world the keeper is now considered another field player.
Therefore, excluding the keeper, it is better for the field to be even. If you keep the keeper and make the field players even, it is easier to organize the relationships and positioning of the positions.
■ Experiencing the local regulations becomes a "new experience" for the children
Also, since your club has opportunities to go overseas and play against local teams, you are worried that they might be confused once they get there. For example, I hear that elementary school kids these days have opportunities to go to international tournaments held in Hawaii. Hawaii probably attracts them because it has many fields and well-equipped facilities.
So it seems they discuss whether to play by the local rules (regulations) or by Japanese ones. Since they are going all the way to Hawaii to play, if they played by the local rules, the children could have a new experience.
I think so, but Japanese coaches apparently think, "It's a competition, after all." They choose the option they are used to. That makes me wonder what the point of going abroad to play is.
When I was a YMCA coach, we went on tours to Taiwan for years. We played matches on grounds where the soccer goals had no nets, and we also played on a court where blocks were buried in the dirt. It was an elementary school playground, so instead of track lines being painted, white brick-like objects were buried there. They stuck up about 3 centimeters. We played matches on such a court. Even in such an environment, referees with FIFA licenses came.
sakaiku.jp
Translated in full by AI so coaches can read it in their own language. Copyright stays with the author and the original publisher; for any detail that matters, the original is the authority.
Featured in Hobbit Weekly, Issue 6Coaching guide names touchline phrases to stop using
More in Youth systems and policy
- Ged Roddy: Why England needs its own version of Germany’s StützpunkteTraining Ground Guru · 19 Nov
- 10 ideas from Portland to make youth sports more inclusiveAspen Institute Project Play · 19 Nov
- Is Your Program Welcoming New-to-Canada Participants? Seven Workbooks to Find OutSport for Life · 19 Nov
- The Equal Sport Project unites sport in the UKThe FA · 10 Nov
