HOBBIT WEEKLY · Original
What age should we start giving more time to the stronger players?
For coachesKeep everyone near even minutes at U10; if you adjust, do it game by game against the opponent, not mid-season.
I'm a U10 travel coach of a mid flight team. We have a 12 player roster and play 7v7. We play 4 blocks/rotations per half, so 8 total, and when everyone is there, the four strongest players get one extra rotation. My philosophy is that everyone plays at least half the game, and if there are extra rotations, the players who've earned those, should get them. We started the season 2-0. Then we played in a tournament where we lost both games to two teams a flight above us. Following the tournament losses, my assistant began talking about playing the stronger players more to try to win. I thought he was overreacting to the loses, and I told him that I didn't believe that was necessary until at least U12, and even if it weren't true I wouldn't want to change the rules about playing time in the middle of a season. I would want to wait until the spring to establish that expectation before the season started. We've since lost both of our next two league games. One was a blowout, but the other we should have won and probably would have won if I followed his philosophy. I asked our town president if there was any sort of policy, and he said that I should be playing the stronger players 60-70% of the game and the weaker players 30-40% depending on scores, otherwise we'll lose the top players. Am I wrong and crazy for wanting to stick to my guns?
Top replies, most upvoted first
- (+33) Age 14 or 15, maybe. No younger. If you restrict playtime for the weaker players then they'll never catch up. At U10, the results don't matter. Say it again, and keep saying it until you believe it.
- (+6) I try to play all players at least 50% of a game, even still at u13. The best players may play 100%. In a game for a league or tournament championship I might cut the lesser players minutes some, but not a ton. It may be worth pointing out that you’ll soon move up to 11v11 and need more players and more capable players. Keep developing those kids who work hard and show up for every event.
- (+6) I adjust game to game depending on the quality of the opponent. Against tougher teams I might give an extra rotation to better players or leave the change an extra couple of minutes. Against a worse team I give way more minutes to worse players. Last game we were up comfortably and a kid who isn’t as good but came to extra optional practices got an extended run at forward. He scored a great goal on a through ball and it made his year. I don’t think he was worried that he didn’t get as many minutes the game before.
- (+6) As a parent - I would stick to broadly even playing time per player. Focus on becoming a good passing team which requires all the players to become skilled (not just the strong ones). Results really don't matter at U10. As long as you get parents to buy into that vision of longer term development as a team, I they will appreciate that.
- (+6) I thought he was overreacting to the loses, and I told him that I didn't believe that was necessary until at least U12, and even if it weren't true I wouldn't want to change the rules about playing time in the middle of a season. You are 100% correct. On all counts. However I asked our town president if there was any sort of policy, and he said that I should be playing the stronger players 60-70% of the game and the weaker players 30-40% depending on scores, otherwise we'll lose the top players. Is also correct. Welcome to youth soccer. Where all choices are equally wrong, and you will be...
- (+3) I think you’ve probably got it about right. The reality is that it is impossible to keep everyone happy. The stronger kids may leave for teams where they play more. The weaker kids too. Both groups may get upset. The pressure does build when you go a few games without a win. Every parent will want your team optimised for their individual child. Idiot coaches think they are there to win rather than develop. What I used to do at that age is similar to you, everyone gets roughly the same with a few of the better kids getting a little extra, but averaging it out over a few games/the season. It...
- (+2) What this guy said.
- (+2) You're not wrong, but that's a big roster for 7v7. Now that may be out of your control, but that may be just as much of an issue as playing time. You have 6 field players and you gotta rotate in 5 guys off the bench, so 1 guy gets to stay on (I reckon those spots are your strongest guys?) so your chemistry and then gets totally nuked. When I was coaching U7 4v4 I had a 7 or 8 kid roster so I had the same issue. I just didn't have it in me to make a kid sit 2 rotations in a row. Totally not fair. But I would have weaker players sub for each other every rotation. This is travel rec right? Or is...
41 comments
Reprinted in full from the original. Copyright stays with the author and the original publisher.
Featured in Hobbit Weekly, Issue 6Coaching guide names touchline phrases to stop using
More in Coaching and communication
- The preseason talk in youth soccer: rules and standards from day oneAprende Entrenando · 16 Nov
- Group management in youth soccer: raising the demands without losing the locker room's trustAprende Entrenando · 12 Nov
- Youth Soccer Methodology: The 6 Principles for Building Successful AcademiesAprende Entrenando · 2 Nov
- What are the grassroots coaching fundamentals?England Football Learning · 30 Oct
